马斯克说:“社会保障是有史以来最大的庞氏骗局。”同意?

Politifact说SS不是庞氏骗局。是否同意?

来源:MishTalk

In contrast, PolitiFact says SS is not a Ponzi scheme.谁是正确的?

Fact-Checking PolitiFact

Please consider the PolitiFact Tact Check on Social Security

PolitiFact Tact Check on Social Security
在2月28日的三个小时的出场期间,马斯克说:“社会保障是有史以来最大的庞氏骗局。”白宫顾问唐纳德·特朗普总统和马斯克的批评者使用马斯克的评论作为特朗普寻求削减社会保障的证据,特朗普一再表示他在第二任期内不会这样做。 [A White House advisor used Musk’s comment as evidence Trump would cut SS?我可以对此做一个事实检查吗?

During the three-hour Feb. 28 appearance, Musk said, “Social Security is the biggest Ponzi scheme of all time.”

Feb. 28 appearance

白宫顾问唐纳德·特朗普总统和马斯克总统的批评者利用马斯克的评论作为特朗普寻求削减社会保障的证据,特朗普一再表示他在第二任期内不会这样做。 evidence would not do [A White House advisor used Musk’s comment as evidence Trump would cut SS? Can I have a fact check on that?] “社会保障是一项透明,法律规定的政府计划,可以通过调整流入系统并流出系统的资金来保持偿付能力,”阿克伦大学商学院财务系主任埃里克·布里斯克(Eric R. Brisker)说。 The PolitiFact Rebuttal No. 1: Social Security is not fraudulent. In fact, “nearly every major developed country in the world has a similar safety net and retirement system in place,” Benson said. No. 2: Social Security’s operators do not take a cut. No. 3: Social Security is operated in the open. PolitiFact Ruling If not, then what?

白宫顾问唐纳德·特朗普总统和马斯克总统的批评者利用马斯克的评论作为特朗普寻求削减社会保障的证据,特朗普一再表示他在第二任期内不会这样做。 evidence

would not do

[A White House advisor used Musk’s comment as evidence Trump would cut SS? Can I have a fact check on that?]

“社会保障是一项透明,法律规定的政府计划,可以通过调整流入系统并流出系统的资金来保持偿付能力,”阿克伦大学商学院财务系主任埃里克·布里斯克(Eric R. Brisker)说。

The PolitiFact Rebuttal

No. 1: Social Security is not fraudulent.

In fact, “nearly every major developed country in the world has a similar safety net and retirement system in place,” Benson said.

No. 2: Social Security’s operators do not take a cut.

No. 3: Social Security is operated in the open.

PolitiFact RulingIf not, then what?