* 西北大学凯洛格管理学院金融系(电子邮件:sean.higgins@kellogg.northwestern.edu)。埃丝特·迪弗洛 (Esther Duflo) 是本文的共同编辑。 I am Grateful to Paul Gertler, Ulrike Malmendier, Fred Finan, and David Sraer for Guidance and Support, As Bibek Adhikari, David Atkin, Pierre Bachas, Giorgia Barboni, Matteo Benetton, Josh Blumenstock, zerek brat-gold, Ben Charoenwong ( Discussant ) , Anthony Defusco, Carola Frydman, Virginia Gianinazzi ( Discussant ) Sylvan Herskowitz, Bob Hunt , Seema Jayachandran, John Loeser, Nora Lustig, Ted Miguel, luu Nguyen, Waldo Ojeda, Jacopo Prabby ( Dis- Cussant , Michael nt ) , Betty Sadoulet, Emmanuel Saez, Discusant , Gabriel Zucman, and Seminar Partipants, Atlanta Fed, Bank of Israel, Bocconi, Cambridge, Cepr, Dartmouth, GSU-RFS, idas, , Inter-American Development Bank, Illinois, London School of Economics, neudc, northwestern, Nyu, Penn, Princeton, Princeton, Sfs Cavalcade, Stanford, UC Diego , UNC, University of San Francisco, UT Austin, Wfa, World Bank, Wvu, and Yale y-rise for comments that helply improve the paper.我感谢 Saul Knight、Arthur Charleston、Nils Lieber、Jora Li、Xinghuan Luo、Eric Molina、Anah Kings、Carlos Restituyo 和 Angelyna Ye 提供的研究协助。我感谢墨西哥以下机构的官员提供数据访问并回答问题。墨西哥银行:Marco Acosta、Biliana Alexandrova、Sara Castellanos、Miguel Angel Diaz、Lorenza Martinez、Othon Moreno、Samuel Navarro、Axel Vargas 和 Rafael Villar。 Bansefi: Virgil Andrade, Benjamin Chacon, Miguel Angel Lara, Oscar Moreno, Ramon Sanchez, and Ana Lilia Urquieta. CNBV: Rodrigo Aguirre, Alvaro Melendez Martinez, Diana Radilla, and Gustavo Salaiz. INEGI:Gerardo Leyva 和 Natalia Volkow。繁荣:Martha Cuevas、Armando Geronimo、Rogelio Grados、Raul Perez、Rodolfo Sanchez、Jose Solis 和 Carla Vazquez。本研究项目中表达的结论由我作为作者独自负责,并且不属于国家统计和地理信息系统 (INEGI) 的官方统计数据。非常感谢墨西哥银行夏季研究项目的资助。 IRB 批准:IPA 00006083、西北大学 STU00217227 和加州大学伯克利分校 2018-02-10796。 † 请访问 https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.20201952 获取更多材料和作者披露声明。
Aude Nicolas 1.2,*,#, Richard Sherva 3.4,*, Benjamin Grenier-Cando 1,*, Yoontae Kim 5,*, Masataka Kikuchi 6, 4 Jigyasha Timsina 7.8, itziar de Rojas 9.10, María Carolina Dalmasso 11.12, Xiaopu Zhou 13,14.15, Yann, Yann. 5 Guen 16.17,Carlos和Arborada-Buscos 18,Maria Aparecida Camargos Bicalho 19,20.21,MaëlennGuchet 22,6 Sven van der Lee 23.24,Monica Goss 23,Monica Goss 25,Atahualpa Castillo 26 25,29.30, Bernard Fongang 25,31.32, Qiong Yang 29.30, Oliver Peters 33.34, Anja 8 Schneider 35.36, Martin Dechgans 37.38.39, Dan Rujescu 40, Norbert Scherbaum 41, Jürgen Deckert 42, Steffi 9 Riedel-Heller 43, Lucrezia Hausner 44, Laura Molina Porcel 45.46,EmrahDüzel47.48,Timo Grimmer 49,Jens 10 Wiltfang 50.51.52,Stefanie Heilmann-Heimbach 53,Susanne Moebus 54,Thomas Tegos 55,Nikolaos 11 Scarmes 55,Nikolaos 11 Scarmes 56.56.57,Oriol feriol dols-dols-dols-dols-dols-dols-dols-icardodol dols-doll dolsocoto dolls-sic.10。 Moreno 59,10,60,JordiPérez-Tur 61.10,MaríaJ。Buldido 62,10,63.64,12 Pau Pastor 65.66,RaquelSánchez-Valle 67,Victoriaálvarez68.69,68.69,Han Cao 13,Han Cao 13,Nance Y. Y. Y. Y. Y. Y. Y. Y. IP 13,14.14.14.14.14.14.14.14.14.14.14.14 k.y.y。 Pijnenburg 23,Henne Holstege 23.92,John Van Swieten 93,Harro Seelaar 93,Jurgen A.H.R.Aude Nicolas 1.2,*,#, Richard Sherva 3.4,*, Benjamin Grenier-Cando 1,*, Yoontae Kim 5,*, Masataka Kikuchi 6, 4 Jigyasha Timsina 7.8, itziar de Rojas 9.10, María Carolina Dalmasso 11.12, Xiaopu Zhou 13,14.15, Yann, Yann. 5 Guen 16.17,Carlos和Arborada-Buscos 18,Maria Aparecida Camargos Bicalho 19,20.21,MaëlennGuchet 22,6 Sven van der Lee 23.24,Monica Goss 23,Monica Goss 25,Atahualpa Castillo 26 25,29.30, Bernard Fongang 25,31.32, Qiong Yang 29.30, Oliver Peters 33.34, Anja 8 Schneider 35.36, Martin Dechgans 37.38.39, Dan Rujescu 40, Norbert Scherbaum 41, Jürgen Deckert 42, Steffi 9 Riedel-Heller 43, Lucrezia Hausner 44, Laura Molina Porcel 45.46,EmrahDüzel47.48,Timo Grimmer 49,Jens 10 Wiltfang 50.51.52,Stefanie Heilmann-Heimbach 53,Susanne Moebus 54,Thomas Tegos 55,Nikolaos 11 Scarmes 55,Nikolaos 11 Scarmes 56.56.57,Oriol feriol dols-dols-dols-dols-dols-dols-dols-icardodol dols-doll dolsocoto dolls-sic.10。 Moreno 59,10,60,JordiPérez-Tur 61.10,MaríaJ。Buldido 62,10,63.64,12 Pau Pastor 65.66,RaquelSánchez-Valle 67,Victoriaálvarez68.69,68.69,Han Cao 13,Han Cao 13,Nance Y. Y. Y. Y. Y. Y. Y. Y. IP 13,14.14.14.14.14.14.14.14.14.14.14.14 k.y.y。Pijnenburg 23,Henne Holstege 23.92,John Van Swieten 93,Harro Seelaar 93,Jurgen A.H.R.Pijnenburg 23,Henne Holstege 23.92,John Van Swieten 93,Harro Seelaar 93,Jurgen A.H.R.13是13,14.15,Fanny C. F. IP 14,15,Natividad Olivar 70,Carolina Muchnik 70,Carolina Cuesta 71,Lorenzo 14 Campanelli 72,Patricia Solis 73,Patricia Solis 73,Daniel Gustavo Politis 71,Silvia Kochen 73,Silvia Kochen 73,Luis 73,Luis 73,Luisio 70,blusio 70,bluse 70,49 García-González74,Raquel Puerta 74,Pablo Mir 75.10,Luis M Real 76.77.10,GerardPiñol-16 Ripoll- 16 Ripoll-16 Ripoll 78.79,JoseMaríaGarcía-Alberca-Alberca-Alberca 80.10 80.10 83,Sami Heikkinen 84,Alexandre deMendonça85,Shima Mehrabian 86,Latchezar Traykov 87,18 Jakub Hort 88.89,Martin Vyhnuk 88.89,Katrine Laura Laura Laura Raster laura laura rastussen 90.91